On December 3, 2024, a significant development in U.S. corporate transparency occurred. An injunction on the Corporate Transparency Act (CTA) was issued in Texas Top Cop Shop, Inc. v Garland, deeming the act likely unconstitutional. This injunction directly impacts companies and their beneficial ownership information (BOI) reporting.
It is essential for reporting companies to consider the following under this injunction:
- The court has suspended the BOI reporting requirements
- The government is barred from enforcing NOI reporting compliance
- Although the court has suspended the BOI reporting, companies should prepare to file in case the suspension is lifted
What is the Corporate Transparency Act?
Enacted in 2021, the CTA was designed to combat illicit activities such as tax fraud, money laundering, and terrorism financing that may involve U.S. businesses. By mandating the disclosure of ownership information, the law aims to shed light on the individuals behind certain U.S. businesses, reducing opportunities for abuse.
The CTA specifically targeted small and mid-sized businesses, requiring them to report their ownership details to FinCEN. Failure to comply would lead to severe penalties, including daily fines and possible prison sentences. The original reporting deadline for companies to submit their BOI reports was set for January 1, 2025.
Key Factors Behind the Injunction
In Texas Top Shop v Garland, the court deemed the CTA likely unconstitutional. The court’s decision to issue an injunction was based on several key points, including:
- The CTA was likely unconstitutional as it was seen as an overreach of federal authority
- The act raised a concern of privacy and the balance of power between state and federal government
- Reporting requirements were seen as potentially harmful and burdensome for businesses, especially small businesses
What Does this Mean for Companies?
This injunction provides temporary relief for companies that were preparing to comply with the CTA’s BOI reporting requirements. However, the uncertainty surrounding the future of the CTA means that reporting companies should remain vigilant and consider doing the following:
- Monitor Developments: The ruling is still in its early stages. The court could appeal the decision and reverse the injunction. It is critical that companies be aware of any updates or changes that could affect their BOI reporting requirements.
- Evaluate Compliance Plans: While BOI requirements are not currently being enforced, companies should still take this time to assess their compliance plans. If the injunction is reversed, companies will be more prepared if there is a smaller window to meet requirements.
- Consult With Experts: Legal and other advisors are beneficial resources for ensuring adherence to any changes in the law. Companies should consult with experts to help determine the best course of action and mitigate potential risks.
This ruling represents just one part of the ongoing discussion regarding the Corporate Transparency Act (CTA) and its impact on businesses. While the injunction offers temporary relief from compliance, the final outcome of the CTA will rely on future court rulings and government actions. Companies must remain informed and be ready for updates as more clarity becomes available.
Contact Us
Calvetti Ferguson works with companies, private equity firms, and high-net-worth individuals nationwide. Regardless of the complexity of your compliance, assurance, advisory, or accounting needs, our team is ready to help. Please complete the form below, and we will follow up with you shortly.